The HxA Center for Academic Pluralism is Recruiting Fellows

Become a postdoctoral or faculty research fellow at the Center in NYC

apply now
Heterodox Academy
Back to Blog
Pexels element digital 1550336
May 11, 2017+Sean Stevens
+Viewpoint Diversity

Liberals, Conservatives, and Intolerance

Matthew Hutson at Politico briefly reviews some recent psychological research that suggests liberals are not more tolerant than conservatives of people who are not like them, findings that run counter to the long-standing view that conservatives are more inherently intolerant and discriminatory:
… more recent psychological research, some of it presented in January at the annual meeting of the Society of Personality and Social Psychology (SPSP), shows that it’s not so simple. These findings confirm that conservatives, liberals, the religious and the nonreligious are each prejudiced against those with opposing views. But surprisingly, each group is about equally prejudiced. While liberals might like to think of themselves as more open-minded, they are no more tolerant of people unlike them than their conservative counterparts are.
Not surprisingly, conservatives tend to be intolerant of groups they perceive as liberal such as: atheists, blacks, feminists, gay men and lesbians, labor unions, illegal immigrants, pro-choice activists, and welfare recipients. Liberals, on the other hand, tend to intolerant of groups they perceive as conservative: big business, Catholics, Christian fundamentalists, the military, Mormons, the police, rich people, and whites (see Brandt, 2017). Furthermore, although research consistently finds that self-identified liberals typically report higher levels of openness to experience and are thus thought to be more open-minded. Yet, this openness is not necessarily an antidote to intolerance (see Brandt, Chambers, Crawford, Wetherell, & Reyna, 2015):
Supporting this idea, he [Brandt] and collaborators reported in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2015 that, although openness to new experiences correlated with lower prejudice against a wide collection of 16 social groups, it actually increased prejudice against the most closed-minded groups in the bunch. Open-minded people felt colder than closed-minded people toward “conventional” groups such as evangelical Christians, Republicans and supporters of the traditional family. And, unsurprisingly, closed-minded people were more biased than open-minded people against “unconventional” groups such as atheists, Democrats, poor people, and gays and lesbians.
Finally, new evidence suggests that more education, long considered an important component to reducing intolerance, do not reduce intolerance. Instead, more education may teach people how to better cover-up their expressions of intolerance:
Maxine Najle, a researcher at the University of Kentucky, asked people if they would consider voting for a presidential candidate who was atheist, black, Catholic, gay, Muslim or a woman. When asked directly, participants with an education beyond high school reported a greater willingness to vote for these groups than did less-educated participants. But when asked in a more indirect way, with more anonymity, the two groups showed equal prejudice. “So higher education seems to instill an understanding of the appropriate levels of intolerance to express,” Najle told me, “not necessarily higher tolerance.”
Read the whole piece at Politico >>

Get HxA In Your Inbox

Related Articles
Shutterstock 1513189949
The Health of Identity Politics Advocates
November 30, 2023+George Yancey
+Public Policy+Campus Climate
Shutterstock 2035713932
California’s Community Colleges Have Lost Their Way
November 29, 2023+Leo Krubner
+Viewpoint Diversity+Public Policy+Campus Policy
Make a donation
Make a Donation

Your generosity supports our non-partisan efforts to advance the principles of open inquiry, viewpoint diversity, and constructive disagreement to improve higher education and academic research.

This site use cookies.

To better improve your site experience, we collect some data. To see what types of information we collect, read our Cookie Policy.